Page 1 of 30
Rate the signature above you!
Posted: 09 Nov 2006, 16:25
by BrontoX
Alright, this is where rate the signature above ours on a scale of 1-10.
10 being the highest and 1 being the lowest.
And please remember to state a reason why you gave the rating you did.
And make a text with some suggestions!
There are rules to this; just so this doesn't get... -LOCKED.-
Rule: Post only THREE TIMES PER PAGE. (Not including comments, those are allowed because maybe you have to say something to the other guy)
You all better follow this rule, or I will kill you.
I will repeat.. -
POST THREE TIMES A PAGE. -
Get it? Got it? Good.
Now being with the rating!
Posted: 09 Nov 2006, 16:42
by xHaZxMaTx
Creativity - 2
Appearance - 8
Difficulty - 4
Overall - 4.66
Posted: 09 Nov 2006, 16:45
by AZ
xHaZxMaTx's:
Creativity: 9
Appearance: 8
Difficulty: 6
Overall: 7.66
Posted: 09 Nov 2006, 16:49
by DeMyX
AZ
Creativity: 4
Appearance: 5
Diffculty: 2
Overall: 3,67
Posted: 09 Nov 2006, 17:01
by BrontoX
Well i didn't rate anyone so i can post
9/10 it's good but it's a little too simple put something around the prince
Posted: 09 Nov 2006, 18:13
by Sir Ibi
Creativity: 4 - Nothing unique or interesting.
Appearance: 7 - Good use of colours and screenshots. Good layout.
Difficulty: 3 - Doesn't seem like you created much except for putting the screenshots together.
Overall: 5.66
P.S. using hazmats three step rating is a good way to spread your votes and also suggest improvements in the right area.
Posted: 09 Nov 2006, 18:28
by YaelDjiel
Creativity: 7
Appearance: 9
Difficulty: 4 - i know modelling the gun was hard (i think?
) but this is just a part of a screenie of it with text slapped on
overall: 6,66
Posted: 09 Nov 2006, 20:08
by Jopuma
Creativity: 7
Appearance: 9
Difficulty: 8
Overall: 8
The blending of the character into the other effects (ligtning on one side and grunge/fractal brushing on the other side) gives it a nice effect. As well as the scanlines over the top of it. Nice touch.
Posted: 09 Nov 2006, 20:34
by Jana
creativity:9
appearance:8
difficulty:9
overall:8.6
i really like your sig its unique!like the effects!
Posted: 09 Nov 2006, 22:33
by underoath285
creativity - 2
appearance - 4
difficulty - 1
overall - 2.33
pretty boring imo. looks like a 5 minute job...
Posted: 09 Nov 2006, 22:42
by weedman173
Creativity: 6
Appearance: 5
Difficulty: 4
Overall: 5
Doesn't look too hard to make but it's not bad, sorta in between.
Posted: 09 Nov 2006, 23:06
by bam_bam
Creativity: 9
Appearance: 8
Difficulty: 8
Overall 8
I really like you set man .
Posted: 10 Nov 2006, 02:55
by bashderq
Creativity - 6.5
Appearance - 8
Difficulty - 4
Overall - 6.16666666667
Not a very hard sig to make but colours and style are well chosen.
It'll be funny to see mine now lol
Posted: 10 Nov 2006, 02:59
by BKize_GT
Creativity - 9
Apearance - 2
Difficulty - 1
OVERALL - 4
Scary as hell o_O
Posted: 10 Nov 2006, 04:12
by SomeKindOfMonster
Creativity -3
Apearance - 4
Difficulty - 1
OVERALL - 3
Looks rather simple to do, but I wouldn't really know, as I don't know how to make sigs. Seen better seen worse
Posted: 10 Nov 2006, 13:53
by | Ryu |
Creativity: 6
Appearance: 5
Difficulty: 3
Overall: 5
Posted: 10 Nov 2006, 14:19
by mprox
Creativity: 7
Appearance: 8
Difficulty: 6
Overall: 7
Posted: 10 Nov 2006, 17:27
by xALFAxGT
Creativity: 7
Appearance: 5
Difficulty: 7
Overall: 6.33333333333333
Sig is a bit small - hence the lower appearance score
Posted: 10 Nov 2006, 17:42
by The Gravedigger
Creativity: 3
Appearance: 4
Difficulty: 2
Overall: 3
If you want to do something with a signature like that, I'd suggest using a different background by using both of the flags as the base for the signature and have one 'bleed' into the other, and then place the crest (hope that's what it is) in the middle, top and position your name underneath. Try to also get a bit better of quality flag pictures also as even their quality can make a decent signature look shabby.
Sorry if this is too harsh a marking, but it's what I think anyhow.
Posted: 10 Nov 2006, 17:51
by xALFAxGT
Damn!! That was harsh .jk.
Comments welcomed - will try harder
Posted: 10 Nov 2006, 21:51
by xHaZxMaTx
So I guess I'm rating TG's.
Creativity - 6
Appearance - 8
Difficulty - 8
Overall - 7.33
Posted: 10 Nov 2006, 22:49
by SliM_880
Creativity - 7
Appearance - 8
Difficulty - 4
Overall: 6.33
Posted: 11 Nov 2006, 03:29
by korge
I know I have a great sig... So dont BS on me about my voting.
Creativity - 1 Good taste of woman, but no originality.
Appearance - 7 - Bleh, see *Creativity
Difficulty - 2 - At least you can paste
Overall - Its just a cut a paste...
This thread is a great idea. Ill have to add my sig soon.
Posted: 11 Nov 2006, 17:58
by DeMyX
Creativity: 4 A flag and some soldiers.
Apperance: 5 Messy.
Diffculty: 4 If you cut it your self I would rate it higher, but i'm not sure.
Overall: 4,3
Posted: 11 Nov 2006, 23:56
by Jopuma
Creativity: 8
Appearance: 10
Difficulty: 9
Overall: 9
Very nicely done signature. The background, render, and text all blend quite nicely into one another. Very good job DeMyX.